1. BrickPlanet Forum
  2. General Discussion
  3. Roblox or Brickplanet?
Roblox or Brickplanet?
Bobux001
Level 5
Joined Nov 12th 2022
Posts 72
Posted Jul 27th 2023 at 1:41PM
Idk
insmedia
Level 4
Joined Apr 1st 2023
Posts 12
Posted Jul 27th 2023 at 1:43PM
roblox got too many people
AppleSallt
Level 6
Joined May 12th 2023
Posts 504
Posted Jul 27th 2023 at 1:44PM
roblox for sure
Markup
Level 8
Joined May 3rd 2023
Posts 218
Posted Jul 27th 2023 at 4:13PM
Originally posted by Bobux001 on Jul 27th 2023 at 1:41PM
Idk
Both sucks
Alt
Level 7
Joined Nov 12th 2022
Posts 55
Posted Jul 27th 2023 at 7:02PM
roblox since brickplanet changed... :(
kurtcobain
Level 5
Joined Nov 13th 2022
Posts 141
Posted Jul 28th 2023 at 1:26AM
roblox.


it goes without saying roblox is THE sandbox site. Roblox gives you all the power. You can make whatever you want (as long as its within ToS) like games, clothing, groups, and event hats if you get in UGC.

Brick Planet on the other hand, you can only do limited things. For example, as of right now, you can pretty much just post on the forum and make groups. You can make clothes but let's be honest, nobody is making clothing brands like there is on Roblox, and I can't see people buying loads of clothing because at the end of the day there's no point in regularly changing avatar.

With the news that they are taking away the feature of making your own games, that just killed the whole vibe for me and probably a lot of other people. For the longest, I've made games on BrickPlanet for as long as I've played. I originally joined somewhere in early-mid 2018. Now that I can't make my own games, I don't see a purpose in actually staying here long term. When I heard BP was returning, one of the first things I did was plan games. Now I can't do that for whatever reasoning.


too long, didn't read: roblox because you can make games
EllernateFan
Level 14
Joined Dec 9th 2022
Posts 4,337
Posted Jul 28th 2023 at 2:10AM
Brick planet. Here are my reasons.

1) Smaller community with means you get to know most of the people well because you see eachother a lot.

2) You can make clothing without having to be on a program which means more creativity

3) active CEO that cares about the community and interacts with them quite a bit

4) good moderation and staff that also interact with the community quite a bit

5) There are forums unlike Roblox. Need I say more about the forums?

I got a few more and they'd each be a sentence long c:
kurtcobain
Level 5
Joined Nov 13th 2022
Posts 141
Posted Jul 28th 2023 at 5:17PM
Originally posted by EllernateFan on Jul 28th 2023 at 2:10AM
Brick planet. Here are my reasons.

1) Smaller community with means you get to know most of the people well because you see eachother a lot.

2) You can make clothing without having to be on a program which means more creativity

3) active CEO that cares about the community and interacts with them quite a bit

4) good moderation and staff that also interact with the community quite a bit

5) There are forums unlike Roblox. Need I say more about the forums?

I got a few more and they'd each be a sentence long c:
You can make clothing on Roblox without being in UGC

Roblox had forums but with the growing amount of bots and users they had to remove them

And Im not going to debunk your 3rd reason
Sir Alex Ferguson
Level 3
Joined Jul 26th 2023
Posts 35
Posted Jul 28th 2023 at 5:20PM
gmod ftw
EllernateFan
Level 14
Joined Dec 9th 2022
Posts 4,337
Posted Jul 28th 2023 at 5:49PM
Originally posted by kurtcobain on Jul 28th 2023 at 5:17PM
You can make clothing on Roblox without being in UGC

Roblox had forums but with the growing amount of bots and users they had to remove them

And Im not going to debunk your 3rd reason
I am aware of the fact you can awake clothing and not be on UGC but I'm pretty sure if you want to make shirts (not Tshirts) it costs Robux.

Also, I am aware that Roblox had forums at one time. It was actually the youtuber "Quackity" that raided the forums and got it taken down.
kurtcobain
Level 5
Joined Nov 13th 2022
Posts 141
Posted Jul 29th 2023 at 12:43AM
Originally posted by EllernateFan on Jul 28th 2023 at 5:49PM
I am aware of the fact you can awake clothing and not be on UGC but I'm pretty sure if you want to make shirts (not Tshirts) it costs Robux.

Also, I am aware that Roblox had forums at one time. It was actually the youtuber "Quackity" that raided the forums and got it taken down.
Quackity wasn't the reason it was taken down.

Sure, he was a factor, but he wasn't THE reason the forums were taken down. Like I said, the main driving factor in roblox taking down the forums were because of the rising users and bots. ROBLOX couldn't moderate every post a scam bot made, just look at old groups from 2017-2019.
snail
Level 9
Joined Nov 12th 2022
Posts 88
Posted Jul 29th 2023 at 6:52AM
Originally posted by kurtcobain on Jul 29th 2023 at 12:43AM
Quackity wasn't the reason it was taken down.

Sure, he was a factor, but he wasn't THE reason the forums were taken down. Like I said, the main driving factor in roblox taking down the forums were because of the rising users and bots. ROBLOX couldn't moderate every post a scam bot made, just look at old groups from 2017-2019.
Fax brother. Lowkey a good thing they were removed anyways.
do
Level 8
Joined Nov 12th 2022
Posts 279
Posted Jul 29th 2023 at 9:44AM
roblox obviously
MasterMalcolm
Level 6
Joined Jul 27th 2023
Posts 19
Posted Jul 29th 2023 at 10:12AM
definitely roblox
Jaye
Level 4
Joined Nov 12th 2022
Posts 24
Posted Jul 29th 2023 at 12:54PM
Roblox, Issac has a history of shutting down BrickPlanet and also (you know if you know) his community multiple times before reopening it again and again.

BrickPlanet merely has more a reopen and shutdown cycle whilst Roblox never did.

Search Forum

Thread Info

Replies
14
Views
38
Created Jul 27th 2023
Last Reply Jul 29th 2023